Pagaya: 5 Quarters of GAAP Profit

Pagaya sits at the center of the AI underwriting story in Israeli fintech — controversial, volatile, but increasingly operationally disciplined. Five consecutive profitable quarters now confirm the 2024 turnaround was structural, not cyclical.

The AI-driven consumer-credit underwriter that turned a $402 million 2024 loss into $81 million of net income in 2025, then opened 2026 with a fifth consecutive profitable quarter. Q1 2026 EPS $0.73 — analysts had forecast $0.20. Network volume $10.5 billion in 2025. Revenue $1.3 billion. Stock around $11–14. The cohort’s clearest profitability turnaround and the cleanest example of how slowly the market re-rates a reset operator.

Pagaya is the cohort’s clearest turnaround. The New York and Tel Aviv-based AI underwriting platform — Israeli-founded, Nasdaq-listed since 2022 — completed in 2025 the kind of swing most public companies never produce: a $483 million year-over-year improvement in GAAP net income, from a 2024 loss to $81 million of profit in 2025. Then Q1 2026 confirmed it wasn’t a one-time inflection.

What Pagaya actually does

Pagaya doesn’t lend. It underwrites. The company sits between partner lenders (banks, auto finance platforms, point-of-sale providers) and institutional capital (insurers, asset managers, ABS investors), using its AI models to approve loan applications that partners would otherwise decline — then placing the underlying credit into securitization vehicles funded by Wall Street.

The model: more approvals for the partner, performance-screened credit for the institutional buyer, and a fee for Pagaya in the middle. Co-founder and CEO Gal Krubiner has framed it as “bridging Main Street and Wall Street.”

The numbers — FY2025 and Q1 2026

Full year 2025:

Revenue: $1.3 billion (+26% YoY)
GAAP net income: $81 million (vs. 2024 loss; $483M improvement)
Adjusted EBITDA: $371 million (+76% YoY)
Network volume: $10.5 billion (+9% YoY)

Q1 2026 (released May 7, 2026):

Revenue $318 million; EPS $0.73 vs. $0.20 forecast (212% earnings growth YoY)
Net income $25 million — fifth consecutive quarter of GAAP profitability
Cash and restricted cash $380 million; total assets $1.65 billion

What changed and what didn’t

The 2025 turnaround came from three converging shifts: normalized credit impairments (the 2021–2023 vintages stopped dragging), operating leverage as fixed costs spread over higher volume, and vertical mix — auto and point-of-sale grew while personal-loan share rationalized.

The market response has been incomplete. After Q4 2025 came in light on revenue ($318M actual vs. $343M expected) the stock dropped 23.87% in a single session — even though EPS beat. Q1 2026 EPS then beat estimates by 265%, but the stock is still trading at roughly half its 52-week midpoint. Analyst price targets average $27 against an $11–14 share price.

What it signals

Pagaya is the proof that Israeli fintech can absorb a credit cycle and come out the other side. Melio and Next Insurance resolved their cycles through acquisition by mature foreign operators. Pagaya resolved its own through earnings. The market is now testing whether five quarters of profitability is a trend or a tour — and the gap between EPS beats and share-price response is the live measure of how slowly that re-rating happens.

The cohort context

Pagaya is the reset-operator case study. If the cohort gets re-rated as a category, Pagaya is where the gap closes first.

Related coverage

The Olam Editorial Team

Pagaya: Five Quarters of GAAP Profit, and the Market Still Hasn't Fully Bought It